Is appropriation appropriate?
I’m sick to death of all these long rants on Tumblr about how racist and offensive it is for someone to wear a bindi or a Native American headdress or whatever else. I don't belong to any religion or even know about any ancestral culture within my family so maybe I just "don't get it" but in my opinion it’s just yet another reason for people to have a moan about something. If people were using these items to actively ridicule or mock the culture they belong to, then I could see where they're coming from, but just to wear them in a fashionable sense - what’s the big deal?Hollywood got Aussie actor Mel Gibson in a kilt and blue face-paint to play William Wallace in Braveheart, and while we were annoyed that they couldn't find a Scottish actor, did we care about the fact he was “wearing our stuff”? No! Of course not. People all over the world wear kilts, fucking Givenchy made leather kilts. Kilts originated from Scotland - should I, as a Scot, be offended by this? I don't think so. Because why should it be offensive for someone to want to embrace a different culture? People wear crucifixes who are non-religious, just as people wear band t-shirts and have never listened to their music (A teenager whines in the distance: "You're just wearing that t-shirt to seem trendy! I've been their biggest fan for, like, ever! Stop making me look mainstream and pointless!"). It’s the same basic conversation. It just seems like a "mine mine mine" mentality. For example, you see people all over the world wearing Coca-Cola t-shirts, with denim shorts with the American flag on the pocket and adopting the American culture but for some reason, nobody seems to care about that? Every person and every country has influences from the past, present and future, from other countries, other cultures. Television and the internet show us things we would have never seen otherwise. Ways of living, ways of dressing, ways of talking; we soak it all in and sometimes these influences make their way into our daily lives. Why is this being seen as a bad thing, and being discouraged?
My e-friend Celia (ceedling) once posted a photo of herself with Día de los Muertos makeup on, and she got an anonymous message about how it was unacceptable for her to wear that makeup when she didn't relate to Mexican culture. She replied with how she thought the message was ridiculous, and how she doesn't need to include a caption explaining the origins of the holiday and how it's unfair that she "wasn't allowed" to be inspired by cultures other than her own, and I wholeheartedly agree with her. Of course, some "hate blog" picked up on this, and made a big fuss about it. But here is the kicker: everybody on earth has the right to be offended, but that does not mean that they're right. This quote from a New Humanist interview with Ricky Gervais sums it up perfectly in my opinion: "I always expect some people to be offended. I know I ruffle feathers but some people’s feathers need a little ruffling. And remember: just because someone is offended doesn't mean they're in the right. Some people are offended by multiculturalism, homosexuality, abortion, atheism – what should we do? Ban all those things? You have the right to be offended, and I have the right to offend you. But no one has the right to never be offended."
I think people should be more open to the idea of sharing their culture. If anything, I think it’s nice that so many people are inspired by other countries and want to integrate that culture with own. I see the term “cultural appropriation” so often it’s making my head hurt, I don't even know what it means anymore. I just do not get it. Instead of ranting and being all “Mine mine mine” about things that originated from your ancestors, why not let people celebrate your culture and educate them about the items’ cultural definitions and significance. You can wear your bindi proudly, knowing what it means to you, but let other people wear them if they want to. It may not mean anything to them but they are not trying to say that yours should mean any less to you, they just like to aesthetic quality of it, and maybe if they knew the cultural significance they could learn to appreciate it’s value more and then everyone would be happy.
Since the dawn of time, people have been inspired by other people’s work and things from other cultures. It’s just how things are. Everybody borrows stuff from things they see around them. There are only so many ideas and things in the world, and things need to be mashed together in order to make something new. Instead of holding things back, and purposefully sectioning yourself off, say “Here, be inspired by our world! Share our culture, let people know!” and in turn people may realise “Hey, I never knew XYZ’s culture was so cool, I want to learn more about that country!” or something.
It’s just strange how this term seems to have become bandied about so regularly lately, I don't remember people being so touchy about this kind of stuff a few years ago but I don't know. I try not to think about it too much, my head hurts.

0 comments: