The Double Edged Sword of Social Networks
Lately I’ve been thinking a lot about the influence of the
internet on the new/young generation, and also how I was born in a pretty
special and exciting time; a time when everything was changing in the
technological world. Even though I'm only 18, I grew up without ever using the
internet for the majority of my pre-teen life which may surprise people as they
forget that the World Wide Web (the Internet as we know it) was only actually
introduced 18 years ago. The internet was sparse for the first few years,
containing only a handful of websites and information, so most people didn't
use the internet or even own a personal computer for a good few years after
this. For example, when I was a young child we had a rotary telephone for a few
years, and a television with only 5 channels, which thinking about it now, we
actually had for a very long time. I owned my own cassette player, and then my
first CD Walkman (which I used until I was around 12/13), and then the MP3
player came along and, of course, I had to have one of those (a Creative ZEN V
Plus, in black with blue accents).
While people around my age, born in the very early 90s, are
technically children of the "Information Age", we also just managed to experience a world
before the Internet. I remember being really young, not owning any kind of game
console, and having watched all of the videos available in the video rental
shop across the street and resorting to playing Bamboozle! on Teletext, which was the closest thing I had to a
video game, and finding it a fun way to pass the time. To a young kid nowadays
that would probably sound like the most boring thing on earth, considering that
they have iPads, Kinect's, Xbox's etc and thousands of videogames at their
fingertips.
What also inspired this post was seeing a Facebook page that
had been created named Bellahouston
Exposed; an online equivalent of a "Burn Book" (coined by popular
teen movie Mean Girls) which, for
those who don't know, is a book in which a student(s) writes nasty comments in
relation to other students in the school. This page, which had been created
only a day or two before, already had nearly 300 "Likes"; including
people I had been friends with at the school. While I was at Bellahouston
Academy, I could say that it was a nice school, nothing spectacular or
anything, a common public school but the atmosphere was pretty good. There was
very little bullying or fighting of any kind, and the most "exciting"
thing that happened in a day at Bellahouston was when some kid pulled the fire
alarm as a joke. So, when I came across this page it really upset and
disappointed me to think how much the school had changed since I'd left, but more
importantly how people had changed. I reported the page, and it was
subsequently taken down a day later, but the upset remained. I thought about
how that kind of thing would never have happened at my school, and how kids
these days are so much meaner than they ever used to be.
When pondering over this thought, and trying to maintain
some kind of explanation or "source" of this new-found nastiness, I
came to the conclusion that the Internet/social networking has given people a
sense of importance, a place where they can share their opinions directly with
the whole world, as opposed to writing something down in a diary or talking
about it with your friends. People now have their own little corner of the web
where anything goes, and is available to everyone. There are two sides to this:
One side is the good side, where people create blogs and use their
"e-space" to do cool things like write stories, or share their
fashion sense or talk about issues etc., but the flip side of this is that others
use this space to target others. I also toyed with the idea that bloggers, or
people who "do stuff" on the internet are somewhat "celebritised"
and judged much more harshly. For example, if you choose to share your
experiences, inspiration, photos or writing etc. on a public social networking
website or blog, then you are enabling anybody in the world with an internet
connection to see, comment and judge when, in the pre-internet past these were
usually private, or at least only shared with friends and family. But now you
can share absolutely everything with a mass audience instantly, it's an
exciting but daunting idea. On the one hand, it's fabulous that someone can
share their work with so many people all at once, but then on the other hand you
have a vast amount of people who are also able to judge and comment on your
work with the same immediacy. All social
networking sites have the option to "like" or comment on an update by
the user, some kind of involvement and most of these comments are there for
anybody to use/see which I think has backfired in a big way.
As a young person who uses social networks and the blogging
site Tumblr, I can speak from first-hand experience that the amount of blatantly
negative/horrible and very personal comments are not only shocking but
extremely common. On a daily basis I see messages sent to blogs that I follow
saying the nastiest things, for seemingly no real reason. Messages calling the
user ugly, fat, awful, telling them they should kill themselves, if you can
believe it. Almost always, these messages are following the label
"Anonymous". For those of you who are not familiar with Tumblr, there
is an option for users with blogs to allow their followers to send them messages,
they also have the option to allow them to remain anonymous. It reminds of the
life of celebrities as their lives are constantly on show to the public, open
to speculation and comment, and that was just something they had to live with
if they chose to be a musician, actor or whatever, but nowadays just any
ordinary person who wants to run a blog gets the same kind of treatment. For
the blogger who chooses to post pictures of themselves, talk about their day or
their personal life are then opening themselves to the mass public, much like a
celebrity does, and then of course the people who read the blog feel like they
know you, and have some kind of say in your life as you chose to put it out
there. Luckily for a celebrity, these kinds of comments written by strangers
very seldom reach their ears but for a young boy or girl on the internet, you
get the option to send them a message or comment on their post and you can tell
them exactly what you think directly – and even sometimes anonymously too, and
they forget that these people are not actually celebrities or far away people, but
that they are just like them and that they are sitting behind their computer reading
that message and reacting.
I feel like this pressure of having so many people watching is an element
to depression and low self-esteem in young people nowadays, myself included.
When you could try on a daring outfit and wear it outside, you may get some
weird looks or overhear some comments but it's unlikely that a complete
stranger would walk up to you and say you looked ugly straight to your face,
but the same can't be said for when you post a photograph of yourself wearing
said outfit on the internet, then people will have something to say. You wanna
share a picture of yourself? Be prepared for everybody wanting to have their
say on it! You can't just say "Hey, here is a picture of me wearing a
crazy outfit!!!" without getting some "wow you look fucking awful"
messages in there because hey, someone chose to be a follower of your blog,
therefore their feelings should matter to you, right? If you thought growing up and wanting to fit in was tough
already, try fitting in when you have millions of other teenagers you would
have never met otherwise watching and judging you as well! I think kids getting
so hung up on being accepted by some online community as well as a "real
life" community becomes too much for them to handle, especially when
people are so openly criticising and judgemental on the web without regard to
the person they are aimed at. I mean you must have heard these absolutely
tragic stories in the news about young people who have taken their own lives
over cyber-bullying. It's just getting a point where it's so extreme, so
ridiculously evil and mean that there needs to be something done, some kind of
"moderator" to stop this happening or at least some kind of change in
the stimulus children are learning from. I'm not sure exactly what has caused
this, maybe just the fact the opportunity is there, or maybe it's rap music and
violent video games. No, I kid, but really – kids used to be mean to each
other, no doubt, but not to these extremes, not to the point where a kid is
telling another kid (a complete stranger, might I stress) to kill themselves
and barely even bat an eyelid. It sickens me, I feel like an old soul because
things have changed so dramatically in the world and society during my life.
Something has gone drastically wrong and we need to identify and rectify it as
soon as possible before these attitudes poison our society for good.
This has been a very long post, and if you've read it I'm
extremely grateful and would love to know your thoughts on this too in the
comments. I hope to use this blog to discuss issues in all kinds of fields, and
my general opinion/thoughts on social stuff I guess. They will not always be
this long! I may get in the habit of recording videos as well, so you don't get
too bogged down in lengthy posts. Anyway, let me know what you think if you
read it!
Here is Angel by Massive Attack.


Hi, I found your blogspot via your tumblr, and I must say I agree with every single thing you said in this post. It's a subject I think about often as well, I can't stop thinking that all this is going wrong so slowly and yet, when you put things in perspective and see how "young" the internet actually is, so destroyingly fast. I think we are not yet able to see clearly all the effects of internet on people, on society, on young people growing up. Yes, we can express ourselves anonymously if we want to, and be as vile as we wish. But we also get lonely and/or depressed I think by the paradox of always being able to be reached (what if you're not approached when clearly you could every second of the day? what if people don't post on your wall, or comment on your status?). And what about our activities? You also mentioned this, as kids we just to play with other things than ipads or playstations or whatever. I used to climb trees. Now maybe this is foolish since I'm only 20, but I fear for the kids that grow up now and only ever watch tv or play videogames or spend time on the computer. Sure, they can learn a lot from it, but as I said, we can't yet oversee the consequences and I think it might not be all good at all. Also, people my (our) age seem to be obsessed with technology, myself included. I resented it when I had to leave my smartphone at a repair place. I check my facebook, tumblr, bloglovin, email, the news more than I should, and I know I'm not the only one doing this. We get bored so fast. I feel like I live on my phone sometimes, the instant pleasure of finding anything you want there. Now I know I won't stop reading books or watching movies or going to musea - but what about other people? I fear the majority of society will become too lazy to ever pick up a book if they have the internet within reach. Ok I'm gonna stop rambling now, this reply is not really structured but anyway, I wanted to tell you that you're not the only one worrying about stuff like this. Good luck with your blogspot, I'm going to keep an eye on it :). (I also really like your tumblr but that isn't really relevant here). Ok bye xx
ReplyDeleteHi Avalon! Thanks so much for your comment (my first comment, yay!) I'm glad this is also a topic that interests you and that you agree with me. This part you mentioned "we also get lonely and/or depressed I think by the paradox of always being able to be reached (what if you're not approached when clearly you could every second of the day? what if people don't post on your wall, or comment on your status?)" was something I was going to touch on too. This kind of faux-connection with the internet, and deeper-set loneliness... anyway you know what I mean. Glad to have this discussion and hear your point of view! :)
ReplyDeleteHopefully you'll enjoy this blog, not sure where it's going yet but we'll see! <3
It's really odd to think that a person just by reblogging some photos they like and posting personal things and sharing their opinions can be famous on the internet, I mean, they're not acting, singing, writing, or anything like that, they're just like us, but so comes the thought, celebrities are just like us too. I identified a lot with the part about the low self steem, people judging you in real life, and you become the same on the internet, it's like two lifes (the real world and the virtual world). I think society will continue to get worse, but then will not be our generation, will be the generation of the kids you are talking about on this text, just like happened with the generation before us. Anyways, it's a good text and I'm sorry for my bad english.
ReplyDeleteP.S.: Angel is my favourite music of Massive Attack, I'm really happy that you like them. Have a good day.
Oh yeah I totally agree I think it's really odd, people create a "brand" for themselves by having a certain cool style or whatever and people share stuff so fast one post can suddenly have thousands of notes and you're "known"... it's weird for sure. The rise of the faux-celebrity is awful. Kids these days just see the Kardashians and Jersey Shore and they expect fame from doing nothing.
ReplyDeleteGlad you like the post and Massive Attack - love them so much! This one TV show I watch has started using Angel as their "intense moment" soundtrack so it was stuck in my head haha. Thanks for reading + your feedback! :)
I'm 13 so I've pretty much grew up with Apple, Blackberry, Windows, all the high and expensive technology. It's apart of my natural environment. I'm balanced though, I am social and do love going outside and getting dirty, read books and spend time with my parents but I also love surfing the web and learning interesting facts, discovering new music and Skyping to me family from the other-side of the world. So without the internet I wouldn't know who my favourite singer was, I wouldn't have any interest in fashion or what career I want to optimize in (I want to start a digital magazine or create a site like Complex).
ReplyDeleteI am a high school student so I can say that it has got worse in school with bullying, but not physical. Cyber. People say and do things in cyberspace they wouldn't normally say or do in face-to-face. So many people go on Facebook and be someone there not, be this cruel and confident little cunt because they are behind a screen. One thing would get said about someone else and it would spread like wildfire because of social networking sites like Facebook and instant messenger applications like Blackberry Messenger, which is the prime of cyberbullying in my hometown.
When I joined Tumblr and followed blogs that posted similar pictures and videos, I started to notice these some kind of cliques forming, not Tumblr networks, but cliques. It might sound odd, but these online friends (who have never met each other) start to become this cyber version of Mean Girls and start causing drama and make people feel like shit. Just thought I'd mention that...
Sorry if this doesn't make any sense but I just wanted to say what I had to say and I'm excited for this blog I always listen to your thoughts and discussions. They always keep me thinking!
Hi Antony, thanks so much for replying. It's great that you can give me some actual insight since it is your age group I was talking about. I think the internet is a great way for people to find out about things they may not have known about before, such as musicians and fashion which is great but I totally know where you're coming from with the "tumblr cliques". When I used to follow primarily fashion blogs there was a very clear sense of that with some of the blogs I followed.
ReplyDeleteYour messages makes total sense, thanks again for responding. Means a lot! Hopefully this blog won't be a disappointment haha. :)